Please select your home edition
Edition
Armstrong 728x90 - Performance Mast Range - TOP

America's Cup - Off the Record - 15 April- Postman's Knock

by Richard Gladwell, Sail-World.Com on 16 Apr 2009
Postman Pat always got the mail through on time! SW
Much of what we have written since the Appeal Court Decision of 2 April has come from various sources, international and local, close to the America's Cup action, who won't be quoted but are reasonably happy to talk off the record, on a 'not to be attributed' basis.

The situation, as we hear it today, runs something like this:

Let's Meet:Early yesterday afternoon, Societe Nautique de Geneve (SNG), maybe eager to gain the PR high ground, began calling the media, starting with the Spanish newspaper El Mundo, advising that they had sent a letter, in response to the previously unannounced letter sent, a week earlier on 7 April, by the new Challenger of Record, Golden Gate Yacht Club (GGYC).

Pity was that the response hadn't been received by GGYC, and in fact did not arrive until a couple of hours after they began receiving media calls about it.

Three hours later the letter turned up, and GGYC duly obliged by releasing their original letter of 7 April, which can be seen here www.ggyc.com/2009April07 GGYC to SNG.pdf

The GGYC note had a few interesting points, being the offer to include ISAF or New York YC as mediators, and to propose a multi challenger event.

'We remain committed to a conventional, multi-challenger regatta in monohulls under mutual consent to be held as soon as practicable, and we would be happy to involve third parties, such as ISAF or NYYC, as mediators. '

SNG had in turn written a letter to their members, picked up by ValenciaSailing.com and which can be read by http://valenciasailing.blogspot.com/search/label/33rd%20America%27s%20Cup!clicking_here

The upshot of this flurry of correspondence is that a meeting is now expected to be held in Geneva around the time of the next RC44 regatta in Italy (22-26 April), all the key players from BMW Oracle Racing will be at this event. It is hard to see them making a special trip beforehand.

(PS: We have since had it confirmed by Alinghi that Ernesto Bertarelli first made contact with Larry Ellison on 2 April, and that the GGYC/BOR representatives have been invited to Geneva next week to 'seek mutual consent on terms for the 33rd America's Cup'. At the moment Alinghi are awaiting a reply to hear if this time is convenient. From other sources we hear that the time of 1030hrs on 23rd April at SNG in Geneva has been suggested by SNG. )
______________________________________________________________________________________________________

Going over old Ground: The second point of intrigue came from BYM News with the publication of a story claiming that 'it is time to look back a bit and reflect on the 1887 Deed of Gift and to what extent it was the work of George Schuyler.'

http://www.bymnews.com/americas-cup-33/deed-of-gift.php!Click_here to read the full story.

The key point of interest was the claim in the final three paragraphs:

'There is nothing plain or natural in the phrase 'Any yacht club having for its annual regatta an ocean water course on the sea, or on an arm of the sea, or one which combines both, shall …..' unless you take it to mean that the yacht club must have an ocean water course on the sea, on which to hold an annual regatta. There is nothing in the phrase to indicate that the club needs to hold, or have held, or even be intending to hold an annual regatta, only that it must have an ocean water course on which to do so.

'George Schuyler made this absolutely clear when – in 1889 - he was asked why that phrase was in the 1887 Deed. He replied 'The courses of some foreign yacht clubs are such that we would not be able to sail on them; we would not be obliged to under the new Deed.'

'So, there you have it from Schuyler himself, it was the ocean course that the committee of the New York Yacht Club considered important when it wrote that phrase into the Deed of Gift it had drawn up. On that basis, CNEV, which - for its annual regatta - had the very ocean course that AC32 was sailed on, was eminently qualified to be CoR when it made its challenge.'

Authoritative sources contacted by Sail-World said the argument raised above had in fact been put before the Supreme Court early in the litigation and discounted in favour of the view that 'having' meant a past action, was not a geographic description of the challenging club.

Quite why it was re-raised at this juncture is interesting, and not really explained. The other point of interest is the fact that it is claimed the article was based on research of stories from the New York Times online archives which date back to the 1800's.

An example of one of these stories can be seen by http://query.nytimes.com/mem/archive-free/pdf?_r=1&res=9402EFDC133AE033A25755C2A9609C94689FD7CF!clicking_here – and there are many more.

The final paragraph of this story in the New York Times certainly pulls no punches, and makes the current reportage of the America's Cup squabbles look rather tame in comparison.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________

Hiring help: We can't get to the bottom of who is, or isn't, employing boatbuilders. A source spoken to by Sail-World, who should have been in a position to know, had heard nothing. Other sources claimed variously that both camps were in hiring mode.
______________________________________________________________________________________________________

In Bruno's wake: The trail that is worth following is that of Bruno Trouble, believed to be in Valencia tomorrow, and not just for old times sake.

We understand that plans for the Louis Vuitton Series, or similar, are a lot more advanced than most believe, and that venues and dates are being progressively put in place.

Of course, if as the smart money has it, that a Deed of Gift Match is the inevitable outcome of the discussions in the third week of April - then the door will be wide open for the Louis Vuitton Series for the other teams who would have been participants in a multi challenger 33rd America's Cup.

Of course, if all the parties and efforts could come together as one, then that would be a truly superlative event - the likes of which we could all only dream.


More to come ....
Maritimo 2023 M600 FOOTERNorth Sails Loft 57 PodcastArmstrong 728x90 - A-Wing XPS - BOTTOM

Related Articles

A hat for every ocean-head!
Stay all day in this super light, comfortable full-shade brim hat with mesh vents Stay all day in this super light, comfortable full-shade brim hat with mesh vents, adjustable head size and removable draw cord.
Posted on 27 Jan
Freight Train Running
Checking in with Cole Brauer and ZaZa Tucker in the Southern Ocean Back at the beginning of November 2024 in 'When diminutive is massive' we warned fellow mariners in the Atlantic and Southern Oceans, then the Tasman Sea that First Light may resemble more of a freight train on her delivery to Australia than a Class 40.
Posted on 27 Jan
FPT Indoor Tow-In World Series at boot Düsseldorf
The world's best riders showcased jaw-dropping tricks and technical mastery. Over three action-packed days at boot Düsseldorf 2025, the world's largest watersports trade fair, the first-ever Indoor Tow-In World Series event delivered a show for the ages.
Posted on 27 Jan
Vendée Globe: Expect the unexpected
An epithet which is never far from front of mind for the solo skippers Expect the unexpected is an epithet which is never far from front of mind for the solo skippers on the Vendée Globe.
Posted on 27 Jan
Clarisse Crémer 11th in the Vendée Globe 2024-2025
Crossing the finish line early on Monday 27th January After an exhausting last few miles in the Bay of Biscay, battling relentlessly and in contact with Benjamin Dutreux, as well as long final hours under pressure, threatened by the winds and swell of storm Hermine, Clarisse Crémer crossed the finish line
Posted on 27 Jan
King of all wins at Festival of Sails 2025
246 boats, 1100 sailors, 100,000 visitors and close to twenty divisional champions crowned The Festival of Sails 2025 wrapped today from the Royal Geelong Yacht Club. It was quite the spectacle, with 246 boats, 1100 sailors, 100,000 visitors and close to twenty divisional champions crowned post racing.
Posted on 27 Jan
Vendée Globe Monday 27th January Update
Too rough to approach Les Sables d'Olonne The storm in the North Atlantic has made it too rough in Les Sables d'Olonne for latest Vendée Globe finishers Benjamin Dutreux and Clarisse Crémer to enter the channel, so they've had to divert to La Rochelle for shelter.
Posted on 27 Jan
Clarisse Crémer finishes 11th in the Vendée Globe
After 77 days, 15 hours and 34 minutes at sea This Monday at 0336 hrs (UTC), Clarisse Crémer, skipper of L'Occitane en Provence, crossed the finish line of her second Vendée Globe, after 77 days, 15 hours and 34 minutes at sea to take a hard earned, very creditable 11th place.
Posted on 27 Jan
Bacardi Winter Series Event 2 overall
'Relative Obscurity' clinches J/70 victory with a race to spare Three days of exceptional sailing on Biscayne Bay, January 24-26, set the stage to make Bacardi Winter Series 2 a perfect event. Miami delivered stunning weather and challenging conditions that tested every aspect of performance.
Posted on 27 Jan
2025 Midwest Women's Sailing Conference
Registration for the event on May 17th is now open! Registration for the 2025 Midwest Women's Sailing Conference in Milwaukee on Saturday, May 17th is now open.
Posted on 26 Jan